How we began:

Dennis & Paula Tafoya began Villarosa Bakery in January of 2004. It all started when the two decided to blend Paula’s Sicilian Heritage with Dennis’s Long Island, NY roots, combined with an equal love of baking. They baked for several wholesale accounts over the next year and half, including Muddy Waters Café. In April on 2005 they were approached by the cafés previous owner about the possibility of purchasing Muddy Waters Café. Their goal had always been to own their own business so that they could work together everyday, so they purchased the café and began as the new operators on May 1st 2005. Dennis continued to maintain his job as plant manager for the Scott’s Company while Paula operated the café and continued to bake for their other wholesale accounts.

Then on July 1st 2005 they opened a second Muddy Waters Café and Grill on Medina’s Historic Square. Dennis was able to leave his job in August and the two began growing the chain. Ironically, on their first day as new owners of Muddy Waters Café and Grill in Wooster they were visited by Tim and Richard Smucker and the group working on the Heartland Point project. The group discussed with Dennis and Paula that they were in search of a coffee shop/café to operate inside the new Heartland Point in Orrville. It wasn’t until late October that Dennis and Paula were advised that they had been selected as the operators of choice.

Since then, the two have planned some unique ideas for the Heartland Point Muddy Waters menu. They will offer locally produced items such as Smucker’s Uncrustables, Knudsen Juices and Smith Dairy Milk products. The majority of their baked goods will be made from scratch in the full commercial kitchen in the lower level. They will offer such items as their 2005 Taste of Medina Winning Cheesecake and Cannoli as well as muffins, biscotti, scones and various other pastry/dessert bars. For lunch they will serve a complete line of meats/cheeses and Certified Angus Beef Products. They will have a variety of salads and soups, including their award winning Tuscan Tomato soup. Muddy Waters Café and Grill will also provide catering services to the lower level conference room that can seat up to a 120 people.

Muddy Waters News

Click here to see articles about Muddy Waters Cafe and Grille

Thank you for choosing Muddy Waters Café and Grill!




Business Hours


Wooster, Ohio 44691

Ph. 330-264-2604

M-F    7:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Sat     7:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Sun    8:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Full Service Bar and Restaurant                
  • Breakfast & Lunch served all day
  • Dinner served 5pm-9pm
  • Catering
  • Coffee Service
  • Ample Parking